ISQM 1

HOW QUALITY CONTROL TURNED INTO QUALITY MANAGEMENT

Written by Doné Pienaar 2024
CA(SA), Registered Auditor, GTP(SA), CertIFRS, CertIA

Associate Director
dpi@altimax.co.za

Firms are now in the second year of applying the requirements of ISQM 1. From the onset, the technical differences between the two standards were clearly identified by many professional bodies, regulators, and related authors as:

  1. Audit firms should now follow a risk-based approach to quality management by establishing quality objectives; identifying and assessing risks to the achievement of the quality objectives; and designing and implementing responses to address the quality risks. 
  2. There are eight components of a quality management system. 
  3. There are enhanced requirements related to audit firms’ commitment to quality through firm culture. 
  4. There is greater emphasis on audit firms’ accountability for the system of quality management. 
  5. There is an increased focus on all relevant ethical requirements other than just independence. 
  6. When it comes to resources, audit firms must now consider human resources, technological resources, intellectual resources, and service providers. 
  7. Communication and information are new components of the quality management system with additional requirements for communication with external parties. 
  8. There are enhanced requirements regarding the monitoring and remediation process. 
  9. All requirements relating to engagement quality control reviewers are set out in a new standard, ISQM 2. 
  10. There is now a requirement to understand quality in relation to resources, services and monitoring provided by an audit firm’s network.

Back to the principles though the most fundamental change is that from QUALITY CONTROL to QUALITY MANAGEMENT.

Quality control refers to the processes and activities that an audit firm is in place to ensure that an audit meets the specified quality standards. Quality control focuses on identifying and addressing quality issues at the individual audit level. This can include activities such as inspecting for deficiencies, tests to ensure performance standards are met, and implementing processes to prevent quality issues from occurring. 

Quality management on the other hand is about supervising all the activities and work needed to maintain a desired level of excellence. It is a system to ensure that the processes used to perform an audit work efficiently and effectively and that the product meets the expected standards. Therefore, all the processes of the audit firm are covered in quality management. Every aspect that may have a direct or indirect bearing on stakeholder satisfaction is taken care of in quality management. Under quality management, a quality policy is established, and quality planning is created.  

Further, quality assurance and quality improvement are implemented under quality management. In quality management, a structured set of policies, processes, and procedures is integrated to work in harmony as a system, thus m​aking achieving goals and objectives about quality easier for the people in the audit firm. In general, we can say that quality management aims to focus on long-term goals by implementing short-term initiatives. So, the prime requirement of quality management is that all the stakeholders in the audit firm work in tandem toward improving the processes, products, and services, and consequently the organizational culture itself. The basic philosophy at the core of quality management is that for the long-term success of any audit firm, quality is the most significant aspect. 

It was Aristotle who said: “Quality is not an act; it is a habit.” That is exactly what ISQM 1 has in mind. Successful quality management is what will ensure sustainability for audit firms. It enhances an audit firm’s brand and reputation, protects it against risks, increases its efficiency, boosts its profits, and reduces waste, and positions it to keep on growing. All while making staff, clients, and stakeholders happier. 

In an extremely competitive environment business survival and business success are not automatic outcomes of having a business. For the audit firm to not only survive but also thrive in the 21st century, quality is its license to trade. And only an impeccable quality management systems, as envisaged by ISQM 1, will deliver the desired results.

wpChatIcon
wpChatIcon
Currency
R
$